Counterhacking China
Since the incident with Google being the target of a hacking attack from China, many of the news outlets that I keep track of have had a consistent background discussion about just how organized and authorized the attack was. We assume that Beijing was behind the attack, at least indirectly, but there are opinions that argue it was an independent attack. Regardless of the mechanics, I think that Beijing is still to blame, as (I think it is fair to say) the government fosters a fear and hatred of Western thought, rights, and speech.
I fully believe that there is a cultural war that will come to a head between the West, China, and Islam. Maybe it will happen all at once, maybe it won’t happen in our lifetimes, but I think it is going to be more than just gradual. Something catastrophic will happen. But that’s beyond the immediate point: the Chinese hacking the U.S. How should we fight back? What is a proportional response? What would be the most effective retaliation? As we seek to improve our world, with computer controlled infrastructure, there is more and more risk of a “smart” electrical grid, or “smart” water system being crippled and causing severe harm to people.
When it comes to China, aside from the ethical issue, we will not be able to attack their infrastructure in the same way, at least not for a long time. Separately, corporate espionage on our part will likely only reveal what they have already stolen from others. But we still have something that Beijing fears, something the Internet embodies: open access to knowledge.
So how do we leverage knowledge into a weapon? The counterhack should be a social hack; a computer virus that opens up / prints out / broadcasts information. Specifically, all of the information that Beijing keeps hidden from its people. All the horrible details of the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution, Tian’anmen Square in 1989. Accurate historical records of the history of Tibet and Taiwan and why they are not traditionally a part of China. The number of protests and revolts that have been suppressed because of corrupt local officials. Facts about stolen children put to work in sweatshops or sold to others. A full revelation of the number of coal mine tragedies and the Sichuan earthquake. Put all of this information in front of the Chinese people, with sources cited, and bludgeon them over and over again with raw information until they are shamed and angered into revolting against the government.
Someone at the NSA or FBI who night read this, call your Chinese analyst buddy at the CIA and get on this. Remember, the translations of the information have to be accurate in order to be credible. This is the kind of attack that all Americans can get behind, has no proximate human cost, but carries the potential for severe upheaval and disruption all across China. You can thank me later.